Chinese stocks at 6-year low
March 31st, 2005China’s securities markets continue drifting down, hitting six-year lows this week.
There is obviously a huge disconnect between China’s overall growth story and the performance of its stock markets. One reason for that ostensible paradox is that the growing parts of China’s economy aren’t the parts listed on the stock exchanges. China’s markets do not to get funds to promising entrepreneurs; they mainly exists to funnel some cash to some state-owned enterprises. And those enterprises are not subject to much market discipline before or after they list. So the companies, and consequently the markets, are stagnant even as other parts of the economy surge ahead.
Surely there is a consensus that planning doesn’t work as well as markets. If China stopped trying to plan who should get capital through its stock markets (mainly through government approval requirements for listings) and put those decisions in the hands of entrepreneurs and investors, they’d be more likely to get capital to firms that will add value, the ones that will help China continue to grow.
But even if Wen Jiabao agrees with that, there will be undesirable consequence to creating such “real” markets. Who’s going to chose to invest in an SOE if they have a choice? If investors have choices, these 6-year lows might be the highs going forward for currently listed companies.
That is a cost China doesn’t seem ready to pay. (Whose interests are being protected by not harming the status quo is another issue). So instead paying the cost of letting the existing markets collapse, they are paying the cost of foregone opportunities. Many of their best and brightest people can’t raise money that might help them build firms that might help make China strong and prosperous.
I don’t know a costless way out of China’s dilemma, and I don’t think anybody in China does either. Growing out of the plan may work for the overall economy, but there is no alternative Chinese stock market that is flourishing while the ones in Shenzhen and Shanghai are inert.
A China Daily story on the market doldrums is here








