The AFL-CIO, the American labor union federation, has filed a complaint against Chinese labor practices.
The full petition is here in a PDF format. An AFL-CIO web page with links to sections of the petition and additional material about the union’s efforts to save “US jobs” and help “our Chinese brothers and sisters” is here.
The complaint is submitted under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974. The Bush Administration has 45 days to respond to the petition. It rejected a similar one two years ago. It will do so again.
I am going to read the AFL-CIO petition, but I already know I agree with the AFL-CIO that Chinese workers need stronger rights. Chinese workers cannot organize independent labor unions. This in a so-called communist country. That ain’t right.
No doubt many Chinese workers are abused and exploited.
NGO and consumer pressure can be enormously helpful in boosting good labor practices, so it is great that the AFL-CIO wants to help its “Chinese brothers and sisters.”
But will improving workers’ rights in China overcome the economic logic that causes some types of jobs to move to China?
No.
The “Chinese brothers and sisters” most in need of help (and brothers and sisters in Africa and other poor parts of the world) are often the ones still down on the farms, where there’s little cash income and, even in ostensibly socialist China, no social security system or substantial government help for the teeming masses.
China (and India) will have vast amounts of cheap labor even with vastly improved worker’s rights. Cheap Chinese-made stuff will continue to find willing buyers.
In my experience multi-national corporations run some of the safest, cleanest factories in China (and many try to police their suppliers, too).
Many foreign investors (direct and otherwise) profit enormously from the differences between China’s low costs and high prices in the rich countries.
Is the overall process yielding improved living standards in the world (in both richer and poorer countries), or is it going to drag us all down to an abysmal Chinese per capita income level? I expect and obviously hope for the former, but I’ll admit my optimism is somewhat predicated on faith. But I am sure I trust markets more than I trust government planners and vested interests (capital or labor) to deliver a better world.
Clearly, as this transformation continues to move forward, the externalities, as the economists like to say, are going to cause all kinds of frictions. James Kynge, former head of the Financial Times‘ bureau in Beijing, has a worthwhile book out that contemplates just this subject—China Shakes the World: The Rise of a Hungry Nation).
A New York Times report on the AFL-CIO petition is here.
The Times story quotes someone who notes that the petition appears timed to affect upcoming mid-term Congressional elections.
The China Labor Watch blog (blocked, of course, in China), is a wealth of information on the struggle of PRC workers.
This article from the China Business Review also contains helpful information and links.